How many sugarplums?

I mentioned before that Mike and I saw Black Swan last weekend - it was a great movie in a lot of ways, and also very controversial (see here). Now Mike sent me this video link about the controversy surrounding not only Black Swan, but also the NYT reviewer who said that the NYC Ballet's Sugarplum Fairy "looked as if she'd eaten one too many sugarplums." Puh-leaze! And then she defends her "more womanly body type"?! It's an interesting 7 minutes. (And, in an attempt to be fair to both sides,  here is the critic's defense of what he initially wrote.) What do you think?